User talk:Mudkipz/Tier List

From SmashWiki, the Super Smash Bros. wiki

Pichu has a 1 Hit KO attack, his fully charged Side B attack, that should be able to get him up one tier rank right? Also, try this, when lets say on something like bottom tier, the higher the person is, the better they are in that tier division. Learner4 20:51, 16 May 2008 (UTC)

Pichu's fully charged Skull Bash is a powerful move, but it's not a OHKO. I just tested it a few minutes ago, and the opponent survived. Besides that, though, I would just like to warn Mudkipz once again that making his own tier list is going to breed controversy. I had the same mind set as Mudkipz and made my own tier list for Brawl, but no one could approve it. Basically, I'm trying to steer Mudkipz away from so much criticism, and I hope he understands. - GalaxiaD 21:05, 16 May 2008 (UTC)

If Mudkipz want's to make a Tier List, it's his choice. But revolving around the tier list, here are some suggestions I have:

• As much as I love Marth and Roy, I think that Fox and Falco are superior to them.
• Dr. Mario should be above Mario.
• Luigi should come a little bit higher.
• Sheik needs to get into the high section at least.
• Bowser and Mr. Game & Watch should switch places.
• Young Link deserves to be WAY higher than 21. At least 12.

Those are just my suggestions, so if you don't want to do them, that's okay, but that's what I think fits. You can check out the Tier Lists I made on my page. --Riko 20:03, 17 May 2008 (UTC)

• No, Marth and Roy are stronger than Fox and Falco, so they can't wave shine or have a progectile, but there better in every other way.

• Dr Mario will be with Mario for a LONG time.

• Maybe that, Maybe that I will do.

• Maybe that one too, but really I've never seen why Shiek is good, but my sister has! (She will Always plays as Zelda or Shiek, she REFUSES to be anyone else)

• Over my 2-D Body! (Get the Joke?)

• No he doesn't. He is a suckish version of Link. Atleast Pichu is somewhat humoris if you main it and beat the smash of king with Pichu. But Young Link? No, only a faster, smaller, weaker and suckish version of Link

• Pichu stays on the bottom, thank you very much!--User:Mudkipz 13:38, 18 May 2008 (UTC)

Shouldn't original characters and their clones be seperated? Marth and Roy shouldn't be equal to each other. Also, why do people keep saying that Dr. Mario should be above Mario? Mario is faster, can combo more easily, and has a better recovery. These are the same reasons that Fox is ranked above Falco. Basically, no clone can surpass his or her original incarnation, and this should be made an official rule. All I suggest is that you rank the clones a little lower and rank their originals higher than them. - GalaxiaD 19:15, 18 May 2008 (UTC)